After listening to Metallica’s new single, ‘The Day That Never Comes’, I’ve been thinking a lot about the evolution
of bands that stick together over time and the loyalty (or lack thereof) of the fans who follow them.
Many fans, I find, don’t always evolve alongside the bands they love. True, you’ll always have the so-called fanboys who idolize every scrap a band records-that’s not the poplulus I’m thinking about here. I’m pondering the differences between fans who discover bands at a certain point in their careers, fall in love with that format, and accept nothing else but that format from that day forward, and those fans who are open to changes a band makes from one release to the next.
I’ve read the argument that master guitarists excel at specific styles. Generally speaking, for example, professional classical guitarists are not automatically master metal guitarists or jazz guitarists. Each works to master of a particular style, but probably will never be masters of more than one. I think this is quite plausible as a simple truth, and therefore think there is a place for most artists to find their niche, master it, and stick with that same formula throughout their careers. I think that some fans would prefer their favorite bands to be that way.
However, being someone who considers himself a creative sort, I know how cumbersome repetition can become. To perfect a piece of music requires countless hours of repetition. Professionals, after all
of these countless hours of work, make everything look so easy in performances. But consider, if you will, not only how many times they’ve played that hit single before it was released, and how many nights they need to repeat those songs again and again while on tours. It’s no wonder to me that many bands start to rearrange their own works or even re-write them while on tour. (Listen to the arrangements of Counting Crows pieces on their Across A Wire release as compared with the original recordings, for example.) They get tired. The fans are hearing the live performances for the “first time”, but the bands are playing it again for the thousandth time.
The natural progression then in my mind is for talented bands to experiment with their own styles. C
ompare Radiohead from one album to the next. Or the Beastie Boys. How many times has Madonna reinvented herself? Some fans would much prefer ‘Creep’ to ‘House of Cards’, ‘Brass Monkey’ to ‘Flute Loop’, or ‘Lucky Star’ to ’4 Minutes’, but I think there is a place for both and applaud the forward motion of talented musicians who choose to try new things. To demand that some bands stop experimenting or refrain from modifying their styles over time could potentially be like opening a good bottle of wine too early – it might be the best thing you’ve tasted, but also might not be nearly as good as it could be with more time to mature.
Posted in Personal
Tags: Bands, Beastie Boys, Counting Crows, Fatboy Slim, Madonna, Metallica, Music, Radiohead